Religion For Smart People
Sunday, March 31st, 2002It’s Easter. For a few more hours, anyway, and I am left with a few questions: Why, for example, does the only Catholic church in Charlottesville get access to University Hall? Why does a Catholic mass–which already awakens a whole mess of conflicting emotions in myself regardless of whatever else is going on–feel even stranger in a sports arena? Why doesn’t Catholicism reinvent itself as the religion for smart peopleTM?
I mean, let’s face it: the church is currently in a pretty bad position. The whole pedophilia thing is going to cause huge problems with the church’s public image. Pope John-Paul II’s stated positions on celibate and woman priests don’t fly particularly well with American sentiments, and
could possibly cause a new schism in the church.
The only way for the Church to save itself at this point is to do something the Jesuits have been on to for a long time–make Catholicism smarter than all the other religions out there. They’re already on their way, despite a few missteps in the past fifty years or so. Doubt me? Just switch between the Trinity Broadcasting Network (televangelists, talking in “tongues,” really large pink beehive hairdos) and EWTN, which is the Catholic god channel. The difference is huge. Where TBN is continuously over-the-top and gaudy-as-hell, EWTN (which may or may not be the right name) is simple, down to earth, and doesn’t try to seduce you into giving money to redeem your soul. Catholics learned their lessons after the whole indulgences thing. Catholicism has had education in mind for years–look at all the Catholic schools that abound in this country, the Christian Brothers and Jesuits–and they’ve been getting away from the “Baltimore Catechism” and the mindless memorization that it entails. But there’s more that needs to be done.
First, bring back the Latin mass. There are many people that will tell you that the biggest success of Vatican II was allowing masses to be said in the vernacular language, bringing the common people back into the fold. And it’s true that, in the beginning, the Mass was said in Greek and switched to Latin when no one knew Greek anymore. So what? First off, we need to get rid of the common people–they’re the ones who are going to be chillin’ with little kids anyway and, if they want a vernacular mass, they can go be Protestant or something. Second, the reason Greek was the first choice for the mass had to do with the fact that, even in Ancient Rome, it was the chosen language for Roman intellectuals.
People these days don’t want religion to be more relevant in their lives. Look around: how much trouble in the past two years or so have religions caused? You’ve got Islamic terrorism, those Army of God dudes killing abortion doctors, the Israeli army blowing shit up, the palestinians blowing shit up in response–religion is changing the world into hell. No, what we need is a form of religion that is exceedingly irrelevant to the modern day man or woman. And what can be more irrelevant than a mass and prayers in a dead language?
Next, emphasize the good cultural elements of the Catholic church. The art of Caravaggio and other artists of the counter-reformation still stands up today as some of the best art of the second Millennium. Hell, the Renassiance started in Italy and, though I’m probably wrong about this, was a result of the Counter-Reformation. Then there’s all the architecture of cathedrals, which is fantastic as well. In theory, the church also should be more forcefully talking about the importance of volunteerism–smart people like to worry about social problems and would support a religion truly dedicated to the poor and sick. On the other hand, smart people may realize that they can’t really help cure the world’s problems, so that might not be a good idea after all.
Finally, incorporate modern day works of art into the church. The type of thing I’m thinking is two-fold. For example, why not commission Don DeLillo to do a new translation of the Bible? Critics everywhere would praise it. The church should also acknowledge the work of modern day writers in a major way. Adding the works of Norman Mailer and Flannery O’Connor (at least the stories about priests and religion) to the Canon of divinely inspired books would get all those academics who dislike Catholicism to admit that, maybe, they’re on to something now.
The church could also do some clever, post-modern references to popular culture, drawing in the smart kids who like their entertainment and knowledge meta. For example, consider this part of the Passion, rewritten to match the music of Radiohead’s “Creep”:
CHRIST (on the cross)
I’m the Christ
I’m the Savior
What the hell am I doing here?
I don’t belong here
PARISH
He’s rising up again
He’s rising up
He lives, lives, lives
Get the likes of Outcast, Del the Funky Homosapien, and Dave Berman to write new lyrics for hymns and the youth will come running.
You see, right about now, the Catholic church is pretty effed. It might as well just give up trying to be inclusive and going back to the exclusive, snobby religion it once was. At least then I didn’t worry about my little cousin becoming an Altar Boy.